Metformin and Malignant Tumors: Not Over the Hill

Introduction

In the 21st century, noncommunicable diseases, including malignant tumors, are the main causes of death globally,¹ and malignant tumors are also the most important obstacle to improving life expectancy. The latest global cancer statistics has estimated that there will be 19.29 million new cases of cancer and 9.96 million cancer-related deaths worldwide in 2020 and 4.57 million new cases in China. At present, the cancer prevalence rate in China is the highest in the world. Breast cancer and lung cancer are the most common cancers worldwide, followed by colorectal cancer (10.0%), prostate cancer (7.3%) and stomach cancer (5.6%). Lung cancer remains the leading cause of cancer-related death, followed by colorectal (9.4%), liver (8.3%), stomach (7.7%), and female breast (6.9%) cancers.²

Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is a group of metabolic diseases with deficiency in insulin secretion and/or insulin sensitivity leading to hyperglycemia.T2DM prevalence is increasing yearly and has become the sixth most common cause of death.³ Epidemiological studies have shown that T2DM patients have an increased risk of liver cancer, pancreatic cancer, stomach cancer, colorectal cancer, kidney cancer, breast cancer and other malignant tumors.⁴ Diabetes or hyperglycemia is associated with reduced insulin sensitivity and increased expression of insulin-like growth factor (IGF), which then stimulates the development of cancer. The proliferation of viscera, pancreas and colon cancer cells also increases the risk of malignant tumors.^5,6 Globally, T2DM is related to an increased burden of malignant tumors, which has aroused interest in defining the epidemiological and biological relationships between T2DM and malignant tumors.³

Metformin is a hypoglycemic drug that is safe, effective and inexpensive. In addition to its hypoglycemic effects, a growing body of research has indicated that metformin may have other effects: it may improve lipid metabolism and weight loss, reduce cardiovascular incidence, inhibit brain function, slow cognitive decline, and reduce the risk of dementia.^7–9 In addition, basic and clinical research has indicated that metformin has antitumor effects and enhances sensitivity to chemotherapy.^10–12 However, current studies have found that the effects of metformin on different tumors are controversial, and the antitumor mechanism of metformin is not completely clear.In this manuscript, the effect of metformin on many malignant tumors and its possible mechanism were reviewed and analyzed.

Effect of Metformin on Malignant Tumors

Breast Cancer

Breast cancer was the most common cancer in 2020, with an estimated 2.26 million new cases (11.7%).² It is well known that diabetes is a key risk factor for breast cancer, regulating estrogen availability and receptor function, thereby increasing the risk and progression of breast cancer.¹³ Previous research has indicated a lower incidence of invasive breast cancer in diabetic women using metformin¹⁴ than in women who used other hypoglycemic medications. Then, a growing number of clinical and basic studies demonstrated that metformin reduced the incidence, metastasis and recurrence rate of breast cancer in women.^15,16 A retrospective cohort study included 14,766 women newly diagnosed with stage I or II breast cancer, 791 of whom experienced secondary breast cancer events, 627 of whom experienced disease relapse, and 237 of whom died of breast cancer. The results showed that metformin use (n = 2558) reduced the risk of secondary breast cancer events, recurrence, and death by 28%, 31%, and 49%, respectively.¹⁷ It was also found that metformin inhibited breast cancer metastasis and reduced chemotherapy resistance in women with breast cancer. Wang JCand colleagues established a mouse model of metastatic breast cancer and compared the lung metastasis and chemosensitivity of metformin-treated and untreated mice. Finally, the authors proposed that metformin reduced the pulmonary metastasis rate of primary tumors and increased sensitivity to chemotherapy, which may be mediated by the vascular effects of metformin.¹⁸ Currently, most studies of metformin in breast cancer have been based on diabetic patients;^19–22 however, a randomized, Phase II, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in 2012 involving breast cancer patients with nondiabetic disease reached a different conclusion. Stage I to IIa breast cancer patients without diabetes were included in the trial; these patients were candidates for elective surgery and received either metformin or placebo for 4 weeks before surgery.²³ The results showed that metformin before surgery had no significant effect on the overall proliferation of breast cancer, but had an inhibitory effect on the proliferation in the women with increased HOMA index, while the opposite trend was observed in women with normal insulin sensitivity.²³ In this study, metformin was used only 4 weeks before surgery for a relatively short period of time, and breast cancer progression was affected by confounders such as emotional state and hormones. Further studies are needed to support this view.

Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) is a subtype of breast cancer with the lowest five-year survival rate; TNBCis highly invasive and metastasizes readily, and the therapeutic effect against TNBC is poor.²⁴ In 2013, Wahdan-Alaswad Ret al demonstrated that metformin promoted the apoptosis and necrosis of breast cancer cells, especially TNBC cells, through reduced IGF-1R expression, but this effect was inhibited with increased glucose concentration.²⁵ Since then, the authors further sought to explore the mechanism of metformin-induced inhibition of TNBC and proved that metformin induced TNBCcell death and blocked stem cell expansion through the activation of miR-193b, which downregulates fatty acid synthase (FASN).²⁶ Wahdan-Alaswad R and colleagues also studied the effects of metformin on the mesenchymal stem-like/claudin-low (MSL/CL)-one subtype of TNBC. The authors found that metformin inhibited the occurrence of MSL/CL breast cancer by suppressing transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) signaling through the inhibition of endogenous Smad2 and Smad3 in MSL/CL cell lines and weakened the TGF-β-induced epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) through the reduction of Snail expression in MSL/CL cell lines, thus reducing tumor migration and invasion.²⁷ Two years later, the authors confirmed that the inhibition of TNBC proliferation by metformin may be related to the inhibition of the cholesterol synthesis pathway.²⁸ In addition, Liu B et al studied the effect of metformin on trastuzumab-resistant breast cancer cells. The results showed that metformin inhibited the proliferation of trastuzumab-resistant breast cancer cells by inactivating erbB3 and IGF-1R, reducing complex formation between erbB2 and IGF-1R and inactivating the Src kinase and/or PI-3K/Akt pathway downstream.²⁹ At present, however, others hold a different view. In 2019, Chen H et al conducted a retrospective multicenter study to investigate the effects of hypoglycemic agents on the risk of different breast cancer subtypes.³⁰ Finally, 1992 ER+/HER2- patients, 324 ER+/HER2+ patients, 1446 TNBC patients and 578 HER2+ patients were included for analysis. The study demonstrated that women with T2DM had a 38% increased risk of TNBC, and the longer metformin was used, the higher the risk of TNBC.³⁰ However, this study mainly discussed the risk of different types of breast cancer in diabetic patients, and the effect of metformin on this risk was low.There is no strong evidence that metformin is associated with an increased risk of TNBC.

Currently, many studies have demonstrated that metformin can reduce the risk of breast cancer in diabetic patients. However, there are few studies on the impact of metformin in nondiabetic breast cancer patients and in patients with different types of breast cancer, and there are some controversies; thus, additional clinical studies are needed.

Lung Cancer

In 2020, lung cancer was the leading cause of cancer-related death and the second most common cancer, representing approximately 1.8 million (18.0%) cancer-related deaths and 2.2 million (11.4%) cancers diagnosed.² Diabetes mellitus is a common complication of lung cancer. The recurrence rate of lung cancer patients with diabetes is higher, and the treatment effect is worse than that of nondiabetic lung cancer patients.³¹ Metformin has been researched for many years as an adjuvant treatment for lung cancer. Previous studies have indicated that metformin improves the survival rate of patients with non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and small cell lung cancer (SCLC).^31–36 Metformin showed dose-response relationships with lung cancer incidence and mortality rates, and the rates in participants with reported cumulative daily use of metformin with a cumulative daily dose (cDDD) greater than 547.5 per 2-year interval were significantly higher than those in nondiabetic patients.³⁷ Sha Zeng analyzed 10 clinical studies and 4397 subjects for meta-analysis. The results suggested that metformin treatment significantly improved the survival rate of lung cancer patients. The authors also stratified lung cancer subtypes, suggesting overall survival (OS) risk ratios of 0.78 for undifferentiated, 0.73 for NSCLC, and 0.51 for SCLC.³⁸ Recently, researchers analyzed the association between metformin use before and after diagnosis and analyzed OS and lung cancer-specific survival (LCSS) in patients with lung cancer. The results found that metformin use before diagnosis was associated with better LCSS in patients with both squamous cell carcinoma and regional squamous cell carcinoma. In all lung cancer patients, especially in patients with squamous cell carcinoma, localized lung cancer, and localized squamous cell carcinoma, the postdiagnosis use of metformin was associated with improvement in LCSS. Similar results were obtained for OS. Cumulative use analysis showed that there was a dose-response relationship among all patients, adenocarcinoma and squamous cell carcinoma patients, and regional and metastatic lung cancer patients.³⁹ Both clinical and epidemiological results suggest that metformin reduced the incidence of lung cancer.In vitro studies have demonstrated that metformin inhibited the proliferation and invasion of lung cancer cells by activating PP2A, andPP2A inhibited the activation of the tumor-promoting proteins Bax, myc and Akt mainly by catalytic dephosphorylation.⁴⁰ Both clinical and basic studies have suggested that metformin has a protective effect on lung cancer, which provides a new way to treat lung cancer in the future.

At present, studies on the protective effect of metformin on lung cancer are the largest and most mature, and these studies included different types, stages and drug resistance of lung cancer. A few years ago, a number of hospitals, including our hospital in China, began to use metformin in patients with lung cancer and achieved certain efficacy.Therefore, after the exclusion of contraindications, metformin is expected to be routinely used as adjuvant therapy for lung cancer patients.

Colorectal Cancer

The colorectal cancer incidence rate ranks third (more than 1.93 million new cases), but the mortality rate ranks second among all malignant tumors (935,000 deaths).² There is increasing evidence that patients with T2DM have a higher risk of colorectal cancer and related death.^41,42 Metformin can reduce the size of colorectal cancer and inhibit its proliferation. In 2004, Yu Xiao Yang et al first suggested a link between metformin and colon cancer.⁴³ A cohort study of 47,351 diabetic patients, which minimized time window bias, demonstrated a negative association between the long-term use of metformin and the risk of colorectal cancer, especially in men.⁴⁴ Higurashi T et al conducted a one-year clinical trial to evaluate the safety and chemoprophylaxis of metformin in sporadic colorectal cancer in patients at high risk for adenoma recurrence.The results revealed that low-dose metformin reduced the incidence and number of metachronous adenomas or polyps after polypectomy, and metformin had a potential role in the chemoprophylaxis of colorectal cancer.⁴⁵ Recently, researchers have suggested that metformin may be helpful for enhancing the therapeutic effect of radiotherapy in rectal cancer patients during radiotherapy.⁴⁶ Moreover, the researchers also cocultured three different cancer lines, SW480, HT29 and HCT116, with metformin and administered radiation at the same time to observe cancer cell growth. The authors noted that metformin enhanced the response of tumors to radiation in vivo and in vitro.⁴⁶ This study was mainly conducted in cell and mouse models, and further clinical observational studies are needed to verify this phenomenon.For patients with metastatic colorectal cancer, the OS rate is still poor, especially for patients with KRAS gene mutations, despite the use of irinotecan- or oxaliplatin-based chemotherapy combined with anti-epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) drugs. Abnormal KRAS signaling plays a critical role in tumor cell proliferation and is usually associated with a poor prognosis and resistance to EGFR therapy. Recently, Chinese researchers indicated that compared with other hypoglycemic drugs combined with standard treatment, metformin selectively inhibits KRAS-mutant metastatic colorectal cancer in patients with diabetes. The median survival time of this group of patients was prolonged by 37.8 months. This significant effect was found in the patient-derived xenograft tumor (PDX) model and a mutant cell model. This study raises the possibility of using metformin to treat patients with metastatic colorectal cancer with KRAS mutations.⁴⁷ This study has verified the protective effect of metformin on patients with metastatic colorectal cancer with KRAS mutations from many aspects in clinical and basic studies. However, this study is a retrospective study with certain limitations, and additional prospective studies are needed to prove the protective mechanism of metformin in colorectal cancer.

Currently, there are many studies on the effect of metformin on colorectal cancer, ranging from precancerous lesions to advanced colorectal cancer, and most studies support the protective effect of metformin on colorectal cancer, although there are a few that support the opposite view.

Prostate Cancer

Prostate cancer was the second most frequent cancer for males in 2020, with an estimated 1.4 million new cases and 375,000 deaths worldwide.² The effect of metformin on the risk of prostate cancer remains controversial. A meta-analysis indicated that the lower incidence of prostate cancer in T2DM patients may be associated with decreased testosterone levels in uncontrolled diabetes.⁴⁸ Metformin treatment of T2DM may reverse the metabolic conditions that decrease androgen levels, and the resulting increase in androgen levels can stimulate tumor development, growth and proliferation.50 A recent retrospective study also suggested that metformin therapy increased the risk of prostate cancer, which may be associated with genetic variation in metformin metabolism pathways.⁵⁰ However, other studies have suggested that metformin reduces the risk of prostate cancer. In 2013, David Margel and his colleagues reviewed patients newly diagnosed with diabetes aged 66 years and older from January 1997 to March 31, 2008, and the authors compared these patients with patients newly diagnosed with diabetes and prostate cancer in the Ontario Cancer Registry in Canada. The results demonstrated that metformin treatment reduced the disease-specific mortality and all-cause mortality of prostate cancer.⁵¹ Metformin use reduced the risk of prostate cancer in men with T2DM in Taiwan,⁵² according to a retrospective cohort study. In an in vitro study, Bing Yang et al indicated that metformin after androgen-blockade therapy induced the apoptosis of prostate cancer cells, weakened the activation of mTOR by androgen-blockade therapy, reduced the number of senescent cells in vitro, and inhibited tumor growth in a PDX model of prostate cancer cells.⁵³

The androgen receptor (AR) is the first major driver of prostate cancer growth; androgen-deprivation therapy(ADT) is an important treatment for advanced prostate cancer, and AR downregulation is considered a preventive strategy for prostate cancer and prostate cancer recurrence after treatment.⁵⁴ Metformin can abrogate the upregulation of AR via the enhanced activity of the midline-1 (MID1) translational regulator complex and improve the efficacy of ADT.⁵⁵ In addition, metformin can restrain the AR signaling pathway by downregulating the levels of AR mRNAs.⁵⁶ These studies support the potential effects of metformin in combination with ADT therapy. The prospect of metformin as an adjuvant therapy of ADT, external beam radiotherapy, prostatectomy or chemotherapy appears promising.⁴⁹

At present, the relationship between metformin and prostate cancer is still unclear and may be related to the pathogenesis of prostate cancer. Therefore, it is not recommended to use metformin in nondiabetic prostate cancer patients, while metformin can be routinely used in prostate cancer patients with T2DM after the exclusion of contraindications.

Gastric Cancer

Gastric cancer was estimated to be the fifth most common cancer and the fourth most common cause of cancer-related death in 2020.2 Epidemiologicalstudies on the relationship between diabetes and the risk of gastric cancer are inconclusive, and the results are contradictory.⁵⁷ However, studies have suggested that the risk of gastric cancer in patients with T2DM treated with metformin is lower than that in patients without metformin.^55,58 Tseng CH indicated that metformin significantly reduced the risk of gastric cancer, especially when the cumulative time of use was more than two years.⁵⁹ The results of Ruiteret al suggested that metformin exposure is generally associated with a lower incidence of cancer, especially gastric cancer, than exposure to sulfonylurea derivatives.⁶⁰ The study also demonstrated that metformin treatment was associated with a lower risk of gastric cancer in a duration-and dose-dependent manner in Helicobacter pylori-eradicated diabetic patients.⁶¹ Choong-kun Leeet al divided 1974 patients with gastric cancer who underwent radical gastrectomy into three groups: diabetic patients who received metformin treatment; diabetic patients who did not receive metformin treatment; and nondiabetic patients. The results indicated that increasing the cumulative time of metformin use can reduce the gastric cancer recurrence rate, the sex specificity of gastric cancer mortality and the all-cause mortality rate.⁶² Kim et al reported a retrospective study on metformin and the risk of gastric cancer in diabetic patients. Participants aged 40–80 years old from 2002 to 2003 were divided into three groups: diabetic patients using metformin; diabetic patients not using metformin; and nondiabetic patients. The median follow-up time was 12.7 years. The results suggested that the cumulative incidence of gastric cancer was the highest in patients who did not take metformin and the lowest in nondiabetic patients who used metformin. Finally, the researchers noted that diabetic patients who used metformin had a lower risk of gastric cancer.⁶³ These clinical studies revealed that metformin reduced the risk of gastric cancer; however, these studies did not indicate whether metformin has a direct anticancer effect. Therefore, the direct effect of metformin on gastric cancer and its potential molecular mechanism need to be further explored. Previous studies have suggested that metformin inhibited the proliferation, growth and metastasis of gastric cancer cells and promoted their apoptosis. Hanet al used metformin to treat three different differentiated gastric cancer cell lines (MKN-28, SGC-7901 and BGC-823) and a noncancer gastric cancer cell line (GES-1). The results indicated that metformin treatment selectively induced apoptosis in the three types of cancer cells but not in the noncancer cells, suggesting that metformin-mediated apoptosis is related to the poor differentiation of gastric cancer cells.⁶⁴ Recent studies have suggested that metformin regulates the metabolism of gastric stem cells and promotes their differentiation into gastric parietal cells that produce gastric acid. This study indicated that the AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK)metabolic pathway promotes the generation of acid-secreting parietal cells from stem cells. Metformin activates AMPK and Kruppel-like factor 4 (KLF4) to slow the proliferation of progenitor cells and activates AMPK and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma coactivator 1-alpha (PGC-1a) to induce the maturation of parietal cells. These findings indicate why metformin induces the maturation of gastric parietal cells, increasing acid secretion and reducing the risk of gastric cancer, highlighting its potential applications.⁶⁵

In both diabetic and nondiabetic studies, metformin had a protective mechanism for gastric cancer, suggesting that metformin can reduce the risk of gastric cancer by mechanisms other than its hypoglycemic effect. It is suggested that when the conventional treatment of gastric cancer is ineffective, including metformin as adjuvant therapy can be considered.

Liver Cancer

In 2020, liver cancer was the sixth most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer-related death in the world. There are approximately 906,000 new cases and 830,000 related deaths every year.² Diabetes is now considered an independent risk factor for liver cancer and has been shown to increase the risk of liver cancer even in those who are not infected with hepatitis B virus (HBV) or hepatitis C virus(HCV).⁶⁶ Previous studies have suggested a reduced risk of primary liver cancer in men with T2DM who took metformin.⁶⁷ A subsequent gender-related cohort study also showed a decreased risk of primary liver cancer in men with T2DM who took metformin.⁶⁸ A prospective cohort study conducted by Lee MSet al in Taiwan indicated that metformin reduced the risk of primary liver cancer compared with other antidiabetic patients.⁶⁹ The study also suggested that metformin combined with radiotherapy prolonged the OS of patients with primary liver cancer.⁷⁰ In addition, metformin successfully reversed or delayed the occurrence of hepatitis, liver fibrosis, cirrhosis and spontaneous liver cancer caused by streptozotocin (STZ) and N,N-diethylnitrosamine (DEN), indicating that metformin had the same effect as chemotherapy.⁷¹ Most previous studies have shown a significant reduction in the incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma in T2DM patients treated with metformin. However, metformin has little impact on the prevention of hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with nondiabetic liver disease. Researchers from the University of Ferrara in Italy used carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) to treat transgenic mice overexpressing microRNA-221 (miR-221) to establish a liver cancer mouse model with a cirrhosis background.⁷² The mice were administered metformin at 250 mg/kg/d (equivalent to the standard 1500 mg dose for diabetic patients). The results demonstrated that metformin improved the liver function of mice, inhibited the activation of hepatic stellate cells, reduced liver fibrosis, reduced lipid accumulation in hepatocytes, delayed the progression of decompensated cirrhosis, and preventedCCl4-induced development of primary liver cancer in transgenic mice. This study revealed the rationale for the use of metformin in patients with liver cirrhosis, regardless of diabetes status.⁷²

There is little controversy regarding the protective effect of metformin on liver cancer, but most clinical studies have been conducted in diabetic patients and few on liver cancer in nondiabetic patients. Therefore, the routine use of metformin in nondiabetic patients with liver cancer is not recommended, and additional clinical studies are needed in nondiabetic patients with liver cancer.

Other Possible Cancers

In addition to common malignant tumors, metformin has protective effects on other tumors, such as pancreatic cancer,⁷³ bladder cancer,⁷⁴ biliary cancer,⁷⁵ renal cancer⁷⁶ and ovarian cancer.⁷⁷ In 2014, the researchers extracted 65,754 age- and sex-matched patients without diabetes and without a previous cancer diagnosis from the database and compared the cancer risk of subjects without diabetes, those with T2DM but without hypoglycemic drugs, those only using metformin, those using hypoglycemic drugs other than metformin, and those using metformin in combination with other hypoglycemic drugs.The results indicated that the extent to which metformin reduced the risk of cancer and prolonged the duration of cancer in patients with T2DM depended on the dose of metformin regardless of whether it was used alone or in combination with other hypoglycemic agents.⁷⁸ In 2018, a retrospective cohort study using the Taiwan National Health Insurance database revealed that metformin use in women with T2DM reduced the overall risk of endometrial cancer, and there was a dose-response relationship.⁷⁹ D. Y. Leeet al extracted data on Koreans newly diagnosed with diabetes and selected age- and sex-matched controls provided by the National Health Insurance Company for retrospective cohort analysis. Consistent with previous studies, metformin reduced the risk of pancreatic cancer.⁸⁰

In summary, most clinical studies have confirmed that metformin can inhibit the occurrence and development of tumors. However, Srivastava SPet alproposed that these studies potentially exaggerate the tumor-related benefits of metformin.⁸¹ In 2012, a systematic review and collaborative meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials did not support the hypothesis that metformin had a significant beneficial effect on cancer prognosis.⁸² Seven years later, Oh TK and Song IA conducted a nationwide sample cohort study to analyze the relationship of metformin use and cancer in diabetes patients.⁸³ The authors found a lack of an association between metformin treatment and the risk of cancer among diabetic patients, even in the high daily dosage groups (>1 g/day).⁸³ However, there might be some confounders or time bias in this study. Thus, further prospective, large population-based cohort studies are needed to confirm these findings.

The Possible Antitumor Mechanism of Metformin

As mentioned above, most studies indicate that metformin has antitumor effects, but its mechanism has not been fully elucidated. Metformin is thought to have direct and indirect antitumor mechanisms.

Indirect Mechanisms (Figure 1)

Increased Glucose and Lipid Metabolism

Hyperglycemia and diabetes increase the risk of cancer. Hyperglycemia can directly or indirectly promote the proliferation, migration, invasion and immune escape of cancer cells. In particular, high glucose can enhance Wnt/β-catenin signaling in cancer cells, thus promoting proliferation and growth and inhibiting aging.⁸⁴ Patients with T2DM also have high levels of insulin and insulin-like growth factor 1(IGF-1). Insulin is the main regulator of cell metabolism and is also a growth factor. Insulin and IGF-1 can promote the occurrence of tumors by stimulating the proliferation of epithelial cells.^85,86 Metformin can reduce blood glucose levels, improve insulin resistance, and reduce IGF-1 levels by inhibiting glycogen decomposition and hepatic gluconeogenesis, promoting the utilization of glucose in peripheral tissues, increasing the number and affinity of insulin receptors, and improving the activity of tyrosine kinase in muscle and adipose tissues to reduce the risk of tumor occurrence and delay the progression of tumors.^87,88

Figure 1 The indirect anticancer effects of metformin include improving glucose and lipid metabolism, inhibiting tumor-associated inflammation and regulating the tumor microenvironment. Abbreviations: IGF-1, insulin-like growth factor 1; TG, triglyceride; FFA, free fatty acid; HDL-C, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol; LDL-C, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; TAM, tumor-associated macrophage; NF-κB, nuclear factor kappa B; IL-6, interleukin 6; TNFaR2, TNF-α receptor II; CAFs, tumor-associated fibroblasts.

It is generally believed that lipid metabolism disorders are associated with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, atherosclerotic cardio-cerebrovascular disease, obesity and diabetes mellitus.In recent years, an increasing number of studies have shown that dyslipidemia is related to the occurrence and development of tumors (Figure 2). Serum total cholesterol levels in patients with malignant tumors are abnormal to varying degrees, and dyslipidemia can lead to the occurrence of tumors through oxidative stress, insulin resistance, inflammatory pathways and other pathways.^89–91 Abnormal lipid metabolism is related to the transmission and development of various tumors, such as breast cancer, liver cancer, lung cancer and stomach cancer. For example, 27-hydroxycholesterol, a cholesterol metabolite with estrogen function, can bind to the estrogen receptor of breast cancer cells and promote the reproduction of estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer cells.⁹² The secretion of leptin increases and the production of adiponectin decreases with increasing blood lipid levels. Leptin inhibits the apoptosis of breast cancer cells through the leptin-phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase-protein kinase B-Bcl-2 axis and directly stimulates the expression of vascular endothelial cell growth factor in breast cancer, thereby promoting the proliferation of tumor cells and the generation of new microvessels.⁹³ Metformin can selectively increase the uptake of triglycerides by very low density lipoprotein (VLDL) and the oxidation of fatty acids in brown adipose tissue to reduce the content of triglycerides in plasma to promote the circulation of blood lipid metabolism (Figure 2).⁹⁴ Metformin also activates AMPK and inhibits α-dicarbonyl-mediated modification of apolipoprotein residues, thereby improving high-density lipoprotein(HDL) dysfunction and reducing low-density lipoprotein(LDL) modification, improving cholesterol transport, and reducing lipid storage in tissues, thus reducing the occurrence and development of tumors.^95–97 In addition, metformin restricts calorie intake, which reduces lipid uptake by cancer cells from plasma and tissue fluid, increases toxic saturated fatty acid levels by inhibiting the activity of stearoyl coenzyme A desaturase, and inhibits the progression of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma.⁹⁸

Figure 2 Metformin inhibits cancer by suppressing lipid metabolism. Abbreviations: FFA, free fatty acid; 27HC, 27-hydroxycholesterol; ER, estrogen receptor; LXR, liver X receptor; PI3K, phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase-protein kinase B; Bcl-2, VEGF, vascular endothelial growth factor.

Inhibition of Tumor-Associated Inflammation

Chronic inflammation is associated with various steps of tumorigenesis and development, including cell transformation, survival, proliferation, invasion, angiogenesis and metastasis.⁹⁹ Cancer itself or inflammation caused by cancer can be triggered by mutations involved in cancer initiation and contributes to malignant progression by recruiting and activating inflammatory cells. Tumor-associated macrophages and the inflammation-activated transcription factor nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB) signaling pathway stimulate the growth and proliferation of tumor cells and promote tumor invasion and metastasis.^100,101 Metformin inhibits tumor-related inflammation to reduce the risk of tumor occurrence and delay tumor progression. The effects of metformin on tumor-associated inflammation at the onset of prostate cancer after ADT were examined in a transgenic prostate cancer mouse model, an in vitro macrophage migration test and in prostate cancer samples. The results indicated that metformin inhibited tumor-associated macrophage (TAM) infiltration by inhibiting the COX2/PGE2 axis, especially androgen deprivation induced by castration treatment of macrophage infiltration, thereby inhibiting the progression of prostate cancer.¹⁰² De Oliveira S used optically transparent zebrafish to observe the effects of metformin on the early immune response of the liver and the progression of primary liver cancer.¹⁰³ The results suggested that metformin treatment changes the macrophage polarization of NAFLD/NAFLD-related liver cancer induced by a high-fat diet, restores the reduced liver T cell density induced by a high-fat diet, and thus regulates the tumor immune response, which may have a role in tumor monitoring.¹⁰³ An observational study reported that metformin treatment for 12 weeks can reduce serum sTNFaR2 concentrations in patients with breast cancer and rectal cancer and that TNF-α promotes tumor growth by activating NF-κB through sTNFaR2.^104,105 In addition, metformin blocks the activity of NF-κB to reduce the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines;¹⁰⁶ metformin also activates the immune response of cancer cells, and these inflammatory processes play an important role in tumor progression.⁸⁶ Metformin specifically reduces the expression of the IL-6 receptor at the transcriptional level through AMPK, mTOR, and miR-34a, inhibits the activation of STAT3 by IL-6, inhibits the STAT signaling pathway, downregulates Bcl-2 and cyclin D1, and upregulates the activity of P21 protein, thus inhibiting the proliferation and inducing the apoptosis of multiple myeloma cells.¹⁰⁷

Regulation of the Tumor Microenvironment

Cancer is a complex system in which cancer cells coexist and interact with several different types of nonmalignant cells. Therefore, anticancer drugs affect not only cancer cells but also tumor microenvironment cells. In recent years, an accumulating body of research has indicated that the tumor microenvironment has a significant effect on tumor cells and tumor metabolism. Tumor cell self-metabolism, interaction between immune cells and tumor cells, tumor location and heterogeneity, individual overall metabolic status and diet all have certain effects on the tumor cell microenvironment.⁹⁸ Studies have shown that metformin inhibits tumor growth, proliferation and metastasis by affecting the tumor-associated microenvironment, such as the tumor metabolic state, tumor angiogenesis, cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAFs), and tumor-associated immune cells.¹⁰⁸

The main feature of tumor metabolic reprogramming is abnormal redox metabolism (glucose metabolism is dominated by aerobic metabolism). Metformin can inhibit oxidative phosphorylation and reduce ATP levels under low-glucose conditions, which can promote tumor cell death.¹⁰⁹ The alteration of lipid metabolism is also an important aspect of tumor metabolic reprogramming. High fatty acid turnover in tumor cells is induced to meet the energy and synthesis requirements of tumor growth.¹¹⁰ Fatty acid synthase is a metabolic oncogene that supports the growth and survival of tumor cells and is highly expressed in many cancers.¹¹¹ Studies have found that metformin has the ability to inhibit adipogenesis and adipocyte-mediated ovarian tumor proliferation and metastasis, and it is recommended as a treatment option for early ovarian cancer, not only because of its tumor suppressive potential but also because of its role in changing the cancer microenvironment.^112,113

It was also found that metformin could inhibit angiogenesis signaling. Metformin reduces the stability of hypoxia inducible factor-1α (HIF-1α) in tumor cells and the expression of HIF-1-targeted genes, including vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGF-A), resulting in slow tumor growth, smaller tumor vessels and lower microvessel density.^114–116 CAFs facilitate tumor progression by providing angiogenic factors and nutrients, serving as extracellular matrix proteins of scaffolds, and providing mechanical signals for tumor cell invasion.¹¹⁷ Metformin inhibits cancer progression by directly preventing NF-κB proinflammatory signaling from CAFs.¹¹⁸ TAMs include proinflammatory and antitumor M1 macrophages and M2 macrophages that promote tumor healing. Studies have suggested that metformin therapy is associated with the suppression of macrophage-mediated inflammatory signals. It has been suggested that metformin-mediated increases in the intracellular oxygen concentration can help to reduce hypoxia in some tumors, leading to the shift of TAMs to M1 macrophages.¹¹⁹ In addition, metformin can downregulate NF-κB by activating AMPK or other unknown factors, modifying inflammatory components, and ultimately promoting the M1 phenotype.¹²⁰ Some studies have indicated that metformin is related to the reduction of TAMs in tumor tissues and the transformation of TAMs to M1.¹²¹ In addition, metformin is associated with a decrease in M2 macrophages because the downregulation of arg1 was observed after metformin treatment of breast cancer macrophages.¹⁰² Cancer cells decrease the cytotoxicity of lymphocytes through a variety of mechanisms, the most famous of which is the overexpression of programmed death ligand 1 (PD-L1), which leads to the failure of cytotoxic T cells, leading to immunosuppression and cancer cell survival.¹²² Metformin treatment can directly increase the antitumor toxicity of lymphocytes, relieve cancer immunosuppression by reducing the expression of PD-L1 on the cancer cell membrane or suppress the function of bone marrow-derived suppressor cells, thus increasing the antitumor toxicity of lymphocytes.^123,124 Recently, reprogramming of the immune microenvironment has attracted attention in the role of tumors. In an esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) mouse model of tumor immune microenvironment reprogramming, researchers analyzed ESCC samples from mice before and after metformin (250 mg/day) treatment and those from mice treated with low-dose metformin (50 mg/kg/day) for 1 week (short term) or 12 weeks (long term); the results showed that metformin treatment reprogrammed the tumor immune microenvironment to an “invasive inflammatory” state and increased the number of infiltrating CD8+ T lymphocytes and CD20+ B lymphocytes. In addition, the number of tumor suppressor (CD11c+) macrophages increased, and the number of tumor-promoting (CD163+) macrophages decreased. In vitro, metformin enhanced the macrophage-mediated phagocytosis of ESCC cells; in both humans and mice, metformin triggered AMPK activation and STAT3 inactivation and altered the secretion of cytokines (such as TNF α, IFN γ and IL-10) from immune cells. These results indicate that low-dose metformin reprograms the tumor immune microenvironment to the activated state, so metformin may be an appropriate immune response regulator and is worthy of further study.¹⁰²

Recent studies have indicated that AMPK can control the differentiation of gastric epithelial progenitor cells. Metformin activates AMPK and KLF4, reduces the proliferation of mouse epithelial progenitor cells, increases acid-secreting gastric parietal cells, and activates AMPK and PGC-1a to induce the maturation of gastric parietal cells, thereby increasing gastric acid secretion and indirectly reducing the risk of gastric cancer.⁶⁵

Direct Mechanisms (Figure 3)

The direct anticancer effect of metformin is related to two mechanisms: adenosine monophosphate (AMP)-dependent and AMP-independent activation of the protein kinase (AMPK) pathway.¹²⁵ The most significant mechanism of metformin is the activation of AMPK.¹²⁵ AMPK is a highly conserved cell energy state sensor. Under metabolic stress conditions, such as hypoxia and glucose deficiency, the ratio of AMP/ATP increases, leading to AMPK activation. mTOR signaling is a major regulator of cell growth and proliferation. AMPK can inhibit cell growth and biosynthesis by inhibiting the mTORC1pathway.¹²⁶ C-myc is a major regulator of cancer cell metabolism and can affect glycolysis and glutamine catabolism in cancer cells in different tissues. miRNA regulation is the basis of metformin’s anticancer mechanism. Metformin activates the AMPK-DICER-miRNA axis or directly upregulates the DICER-miRNA axis to further decrease the levels of c-MYC, HIF-1α and IRS2, eventually disrupting the metabolism of tumor cells and inhibiting the occurrence and development of tumors.¹²⁷ Previous studies have suggested that compared with that in human plasma, the folic acid concentration in standard cell culture medium from cancer cell lines is relatively high. Metformin can be used as an anti-folic acid chemotherapy drug to inhibit tumor proliferation by activating the ATM/AMPK tumor inhibition signaling pathway, changing the carbon flow of the folate-related single carbon metabolic pathway, and disrupting folate metabolism.¹²⁸ P53 has many biological functions, including regulating cell growth, survival, development, senescence and senescence.¹²⁹ AMPK phosphorylation induces cell cycle arrest by direct phosphorylation of p53.¹³⁰ Studies have suggested that metformin inhibits the proliferation and induces the apoptosis of cervical cancer cells by activating AMPK or other signaling pathways, downregulating cyclin D1 and upregulating p53.¹³⁰

Figure 3 The direct anticancer effects of metformin. Metformin inhibits cancer by activating AMPK and p53 and inhibitingmTORC, cyclin D1, ROS-JNK/c-Jun and TGFR-β2.

Cell apoptosis, autophagy and pyroptosis are important mechanisms of programmed cell death. Many studies have suggested that apoptosis and autophagy play a major role in inflammation, immune responses and cancer progression.^131,132 Metformin inhibits the proliferation of myeloma cells by activating AMPK to restrain the mTORC1 and mTORC2 pathways, further inducing autophagy and arresting the cell cycle.¹³³ Liu S and others have indicated that metformin inhibits the proliferation, invasion and metastasis of gastric cancer cells by inducing Beclin 1-dependent autophagy through the AMPK mTOR signaling pathway.¹³⁴ Pyroptosis is a newly discovered proinflammatory programmed cell death pathway that is characterized by the continuous expansion of cells until membrane rupture, leading to the release of cell contents and the activation of an intense inflammatory response. Recently, Zheng Z showed that metformin activates the AMPK/SIRT1/NF-κB signaling pathway, promotes the accumulation of Bax and the release of cytochrome C, and ultimately triggers the activation of caspase-3 and the cleavage of GSDME in cancer cells, leading to pyroptosis. In addition, these authors found that metformin promotes mitochondrial dysfunction that induces the AMPK/SIRT1 pathway, leading to pyroptosis.¹³⁵ Induced cell pyroptosis is considered a new therapeutic protocol for the treatment of various cancers. Leucine-rich protein-1 (PELP1), a scaffolding oncogene, is upregulated in advanced ESCC and is highly related to cancer progression and patient prognosis. Wang L et al found that metformin treatment resulted in gasdermin D (GSDMD)-mediated pyroptosis, which was abrogated by forced expression of PELP1. The authors noted that metformin induced pyroptosisinESCC cells by targeting the miR-497/PELP1 axis.Their results showed that metformin and any other pyroptosis-inducing reagents have tremendous potential in treating chemotherapy- and radiation-resistant ESCC.¹³⁶ Induced cell apoptosis is considered a new therapeutic protocol for the treatment of various cancers.

Metformin also inhibits the development and progression of tumors independent of the AMPK signaling pathway. Metformin induces apoptosis and autophagy in ESCC cells by inactivating STAT3 and restraining Bcl-2¹³⁷ and induces apoptotic pathways by activating caspase-3 in human adrenocortical and pancreatic cancer cells.^138,139 In addition, metformin induces mitochondrial apoptosis in cancer cells by increasing the protein levels of Bax and cleaved caspase-3 in ovarian cancer cells.¹⁴⁰ Metformin also inhibits the growth and invasion of hepatoma cells through the PI3K/Akt/mTOR pathway and induces the apoptosis and autophagy of hepatoma cells.¹⁴¹ Recent studies have suggested that metformin induces cell cycle arrest and programmed cell death, including apoptosis and autophagy, in human osteosarcoma cells through the ros-jnk/c-Jun cascade.¹⁴² In addition, metformin can further promote the apoptosis of primary breast cancer cells by downregulating cyclin D1 and upregulating p53 independent of the AMPK signaling pathway.¹⁴³ Ji-Hye Park et al studied the effect of metformin on drug-resistant colorectal cancer. The results suggested that metformin improves the sensitivity of these cell lines to chemotherapeutic drugs by inhibiting the proliferation of rectal cancer cells, inhibiting their colony formation ability and increasing their apoptosis. In addition, metformin and diphenylguanidine inhibit the expression of snail and twist mediated by transforming growth factor beta receptor 2 (TGFR-β2) to affect the migration and invasion of rectal cancer cells.¹⁴⁴

Conclusion and Prospective

Metformin is the first-choice antidiabetic drug for T2DM; its molecular target is AMPK. AMPK is involved in many metabolic processes and plays an important role in many contexts. Metformin not only lowers blood glucose levels and ameliorates insulin resistance but also inhibits lipolysis and reduces cardiovascular complications in patients with T2DM. In recent years, metformin was declared to have antiaging, hair growth-promoting, cognitive impairment-reversing, and antitumor effects.

At present, most clinical studies have proven that metformin treatment can reduce the risk of cancer and improve the survival of cancer patients. However, the benefits of metformin for some cancer patients are not clear. Metformin may be related to the rate of progression of these cancers, their special mechanisms and their therapeutic effect. The results are also related to the time window deviation of some clinical studies, the inclusion of population, study design and the failure to consider the economic conditions of patients. In addition, metformin is taken orally. Due to its polarity, metformin needs to enter cells through membrane transporters. Organic cation transporters (OCTs) are important transporters for metformin to enter cells, and tumor cells can express OCT1. However, different tumor cells have different expression levels of OCT1, and a decreased expression of OCT1 in tumor cells will reduce the uptake of metformin, thus affecting the effective concentration of metformin in cells and the exertion of its effects, which may also lead to the difference in the benefits of metformin in different tumors. Currently, the protective effects of metformin on many types of cancer, such as lung cancer, gastric cancer, colorectal cancer and liver cancer, are less controversial, and metformin may be considered adjuvant therapy in these cancer patients. However, the effects of metformin on breast cancer and prostate cancer are still debated, and it is not recommended to be used in cancer patients without diabetes. Additional prospective studies are needed to verify the effect of metformin on different types of cancer. In addition, further evaluation of OCT1expression in different tumor cells is conducive to better understanding the antitumor effect of metformin.In addition, most studies on tumors with metformin were based on T2DM, with few related studies on cancer without DM. We hope that an increasing number of in-depth studies will be conducted to further explore the relationship between metformin and cancer and provide strong evidence for the clinical application of metformin in cancer patients.

Most basic studies have indicated that metformin inhibits the growth of tumor cells and promotes cell apoptosis, while clinical studies have yielded inconsistent results. This disparity can be explained by the difference in metformin concentration between basic research and clinical research. The maximum recommended dose of metformin for T2DM is 2500 mg/d, and the dose used in cell and mouse studies is far higher than that in human blood.Metformin directly activates the AMPK signaling pathway to inhibit the occurrence and development of tumors, inhibits the production of ROS via mitochondrial respiratory chain complex I, induces the activation of mTORC1, inhibits cyclin D1 and then inhibits the growth of tumors. In addition, metformin indirectly inhibits tumor growth, proliferation, invasion and metastasis by decreasing blood glucose levels, attenuating insulin resistance, reducing inflammation and improving the tumor microenvironment. Glycolysis plays a critical role in the energy metabolism of tumor cells and metformin has a certain inhibitory effect on glycolysis.At present, studies on the mechanism of metformin’s antitumor effects are becoming increasingly in-depth, but some controversies remain. Additional research is needed to uncover the mystery of metformin to allow for its better application in the clinic and to achieve better inhibition of tumor growth.