Back to Browse Journals » International Journal of Women's Health » Volume 5

Safety and effectiveness of termination services performed by doctors versus midlevel providers: a systematic review and analysis

Authors Ngo TD, Park MH, Free C

Published Date January 2013 Volume 2013:5 Pages 9—17

DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.2147/IJWH.S39627

Received 27 October 2012, Accepted 21 November 2012, Published 4 January 2013

Thoai D Ngo,1,2 Min Hae Park,1 Caroline Free2

1Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Team, Health System Department, Marie Stopes International, UK; 2Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK

Objective: Training midlevel providers (MLPs) to conduct surgical abortions and manage medical abortions has been proposed as a way to increase women's access to safe abortion. This paper reviews the evidence that compares the effectiveness and safety of abortion procedures administered by MLPs versus doctors.
Methods: A systematic search was conducted of published trials and comparison studies assessing the effectiveness and/or safety of abortion provided by MLPs compared to doctors. The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, MEDLINE, and Popline were searched. The primary outcomes of interest were: (1) incomplete or failed abortion; and (2) measures of safety (adverse events and complications) of abortion procedures administered by MLPs and doctors. Odds ratios (ORs) and their 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated for each study. Data were synthesized in a narrative fashion.
Findings: Five studies were included in this review (n = 8539 women), comprising two randomized controlled trials (RCTs) (n = 3821) and three prospective cohort studies (n = 4718). In total, 4198 women underwent a procedure administered by an MLP, and 4341 women underwent a physician-administered procedure. Studies took place in the US, Nepal, South Africa, Vietnam, and India. Four studies used surgical abortion with maximum gestational ages ranging from 10 to 16+ weeks, while a medical abortion study had gestational ages up to 9 weeks. In RCTs, the effect estimates for incomplete or failed abortion for procedures performed by MLPs compared with doctors were OR = 2.00 (95% CI 0.85–4.68) for surgical abortion, and OR = 0.69 (95% CI 0.34–1.37) for medical abortion. Complications were rare among both provider types (1.2%–3.1%; OR = 1.80, 95% CI 0.83–3.90 for surgical abortions), and no deaths were reported.
Conclusion: There were no statistical differences in incomplete abortion and complications for first trimester surgical and medical abortion up to 9 weeks performed by MLPs compared with physicians. Further studies are required to establish more precise effect estimates.

Keywords: abortion, misoprostol, manual vacuum aspiration, medical abortion

Download Article [PDF] View Full Text [HTML] 

Creative Commons License This work is published by Dove Medical Press Limited, and licensed under Creative Commons Attribution - Non Commercial (unported, v3.0) License. The full terms of the License are available at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/. Non-commercial uses of the work are permitted without any further permission from Dove Medical Press Limited, provided the work is properly attributed. Permissions beyond the scope of the License are administered by Dove Medical Press Limited. Information on how to request permission may be found at: http://www.dovepress.com/permissions.php

Other articles by this author:

Women’s perspectives on termination service delivery in Vietnam: a cross-sectional survey in three provinces

Ngo TD, Free C, Le HT, Edwards P, Pham KH, Nguyen YB, Nguyen TH

International Journal of Women's Health 2014, 6:927-933

Published Date: 30 October 2014

Medical abortion practices among private providers in Vietnam

Park MH, Nguyen TH, Dang AN, Ngo TD

International Journal of Women's Health 2013, 5:593-598

Published Date: 24 September 2013

Readers of this article also read:

Therapeutic antitumor efficacy of tumor-derived autophagosome (DRibble) vaccine on head and neck cancer

Su H, Luo Q, Xie H, Huang XF, Ni YH, Mou YB, Hu QG

International Journal of Nanomedicine 2015, 10:1921-1930

Published Date: 10 March 2015

Enhanced photodynamic leishmanicidal activity of hydrophobic zinc phthalocyanine within archaeolipids containing liposomes [Corrigendum]

Perez AP, Casasco A, Schilrreff P, Defain Tesoriero MV, Duempelmann L, Pappalardo JS, Altube MJ, Higa L, Morilla MJ, Petray P, Romero EL

International Journal of Nanomedicine 2015, 10:169-170

Published Date: 29 December 2014

Quantitative evaluation in combination with nonquantitative evaluation in early patellar cartilage osteoarthritis at 3.0 T

Zuo HD, Yao WW, Qu N, Yang SX, Wang JH, Cui XJ

Clinical Interventions in Aging 2014, 9:1133-1143

Published Date: 16 July 2014

Burden of comorbidities among Japanese patients with atrial fibrillation: a case study of dyspepsia [Corrigendum]

Kinoshita Y, DiBonaventura M, Rossi B, Iwamoto K, Wang ECY, Briere JB

Clinical and Experimental Gastroenterology 2013, 6:193-194

Published Date: 23 September 2013

Rotavirus gastroenteritis in children under 5 years in the Kingdom of Bahrain: hospital-based surveillance

Al Musawi M, Zainaldeen H, Shafi F, Anis S, DeAntonio R

Clinical Epidemiology 2013, 5:269-275

Published Date: 6 August 2013

Bimatoprost ophthalmic solution 0.03% lowered intraocular pressure of normal-tension glaucoma with minimal adverse events. [Corrigendum]

Tsumura T, Yoshikawa K, Suzumura H, Kimura T, Sasaki S, Kimura I, Takeda R

Clinical Ophthalmology 2013, 7:129-130

Published Date: 16 January 2013

Malignant conjunctival T cell lymphoma diagnosed by punch biopsy as a primary manifestation of systemic cancer

Isola V, Mazzacane D, Defelice N, D'Amico A, Dezza L, Marti A, Pece A

Clinical Ophthalmology 2012, 6:777-780

Published Date: 21 May 2012

Corrigendum

Schneider EW, Johnson MW

Clinical Ophthalmology 2011, 5:1315-1316

Published Date: 16 September 2011

Corrigendum - Functional mobility and balance in community dwelling elderly submitted to multisensory versus strength exercises

Alfieri FM, Riberto M, Gatz LS, et al

Clinical Interventions in Aging 2010, 5:363-364

Published Date: 24 November 2010

Misregulation of rhodopsin phosphorylation and dephosphorylation found in P23H rat retinal degeneration

Yoshiyuki Saito, Hiroshi Ohguro, Ikuyo Ohguro, Noriyuki Sato, Futoshi Ishikawa, et al

Clinical Ophthalmology 2008, 2:821-828

Published Date: 30 October 2008